BITTER CHRISTMAS (AMARGA NAVIDAD)
(Check out Brandon Wilson’s Bitter Christmas movie review, it’s in theaters now. Seen it? Join the conversation with HtN on our Letterboxd Page.)
Sometimes the greatest enemy to a filmmaker’s legacy is their own consistency. Romanticism may never have impacted the cinema formally the way modernism and postmodernism have, but it has very much shaped how we think of filmmakers and what makes them great. In keeping with this, we love a tormented (always male, almost always straight, almost always white) genius who turns filmmaking into an act of war. That war can be waged against the studios and the establishment, the encroachment of new technology, the elements themselves, or all of the above. And if the filmmaker seems in danger of risking their health or wellbeing in the case of that quest, a legend is born.
Absolutely none of that applies to Pedro Almodóvar. He is not the kind of filmmaker that inspires this kind of lionizing, and in the heavily hetero-masculine coded world of filmdom, this means that despite him being unquestionably a master filmmaker, Almodóvar still seems just a bit underrated. Even if he has won many of the film world’s highest honors. When he was given the Career Golden Lion for Livetime Achievement in 2019 at the Venice Film Festival, jury president Lucrecia Martel spoke movingly of Almodóvar: “Long before women, homosexuals, and trans people got collectively fed up with the miserable place we had in history, Pedro had already made us heroines.” Five years later, he won the Golden Lion for his English language film The Room Next Door.
So while film bros may not put him on a pedestal, Almodóvar is cherished and valued. And yet, I sometimes think the fact that for 46 years he has cranked out a film every 2 to 3 years like clockwork (a feat more and more rare these days), tends to make us take Almodóvar for granted. And unlike those Romantic film heroes, his work is above all, deeply consistent. Hard to build lore around that.
His latest is Amarga Navidad, or in English, Bitter Christmas. The title comes from a song by Chavela Vargas (1919 – 2012), the lesbian Costa Rica-born Mexican singer that Almodóvar adores (he even produced a documentary about her in her later years). Vargas’ music haunts the film, and the importance of Vargas to the film becomes clear in a key moment when the writer-director fixes on the face of two characters as they listen to one of Vargas’ late recordings. Tears well up and fall as they listen to Vargas, her voice all but gone, more or less speaking the lyrics instead of singing them but still imbuing the words with her magic.
Almodóvar is 77. It was impossible not to reflect on this moment showcasing late Chavela Vargas that the filmmaker is now in the final act of his storied career. And that moment brought me to tears as well, thinking about how singular Almodóvar (who else bridges Golden Age Hollywood with Punk Modernism so deftly) is and how little time we may have left with him.
Amarga Navidad is a deeply reflexive piece that involves a filmmaker clearly based on Almodóvar (not the first time he has done that, or even the second time) who is grappling with trying to stay relevant despite achieving elder statesman status and the ethics of using the people around you as fodder for your art.
Argentinian actor Leonardo Sbaraglia plays Raúl, a filmmaker we regularly see typing away furiously on his laptop in one of those trademark gorgeous Almodóvar homes (this is production designer Antxón Gómez’s 13th collaboration with the director; they go back to 1997 and Live Flesh). Raúl is doted on by his younger hunky boyfriend Santi (Quim Gutiérrez) and his devoted longtime assistant Mónica (played by Aitana Sánchez-Gijón). The screenplay he’s writing makes up the second of the film’s parallel narratives. Raúl’s script is set in 2004 and tells the story of commercial director Elsa (Bárbara Lennie) and her younger hunky boyfriend Bonifacio (Patrick Criado).
Elsa is Raúl’s gender flipped avatar in a world Raúl patterns after the world around him, both past and present combined. Elsa, once a promising filmmaker whose second feature flopped but lived on as a cult film, has settled for a career directing commercials. One such commercial brought Bonifacio into her life. Elsa begins to feel the need to be creative as she once was. And in this narrative, she begins to fixate on her grieving friend Natalia (played by Milena Smit, who last worked with Almodóvar on 2021’s Parallel Mothers).
Natalia is drowning in guilt and grief following a tragic accident and Elsa invites her on a getaway to the island of Lanzarote (a stunning landscape Almodóvar visited in 2009’s Broken Embraces; not coincidentally his latest is his first film shot in 2.4:1 since Broken Embraces). And it becomes increasingly clear that Elsa has invited Natalia to not only help her process her grief, but to mine it for her own writing.
As he constructs the Elsa narrative, Raúl is mining the pain of Mónica’s partner as an inspiration for Natalia. But in the setting up the Elsa narrative, he seems to be at least in part acknowledging the moral dubiousness of his endeavor. The film builds and builds toward the inevitable confrontation between Raúl and Mónica which becomes both an emotional and intellectual duel, fueled by the intense feelings of intimate friends of decades.
The film is briskly edited by Teresa Font, his editor since 2019’s Pain and Glory, and beautifully photographed by Pau Esteve Birba who has never worked with the director before. The craft all around is undeniable, but compared to Almodóvar’s last three features (all in his top 10 in my book), this film can’t help but seem minor in comparison; akin to his film Julieta (2016) which was as usual, beautifully if not passionately, made.
The film ends as it begins, with the act of writing, and one hopes the maestro has at least one more film in him. This is an effective meditation on mortality and the ethics of storytelling, but it would not be my choice to end one of cinema’s greatest bodies of work.
– Brandon D. Wilson (@GeniusBastard)



